Umm I love Duffy, drink diet coke, and feel that woman are constantly dumbed down or sexualized in advertising but I'm not offended by this ad and I think the F Word overreacted which wouldn't bother me so much except woman are already accused of being too sensitive and posts like theirs actually hurt us. Of course everyone is entitled to their opinion but I think they got it wrong this time. I can't believe any woman would desire an ad that says, "I am special, so are you." I'm not special and no one needs to tell me that to get me to buy their product. It's condescending plus it reminds me of the, "everybody gets a trophy" mantra of little kids sports because we want our kids to have high self esteem so they can do well in life when acknowledging failure is the only way to make real winners. Plus kids with high self esteem are the worst little shits out there.
I think making idols out of people whether it's Duffy, Heath Ledger, etc is a bad idea. We are all human, and when you try to make someone perfect you ruin who they are. I admire Duffy, love her music, and wish I had her talent, but I don't think she's a super woman and neither should anyone else. She's a strong, successful woman but since when did being a strong and successful woman mean you must be a super hero because no mere mortal could produce such a feat?! Perhaps The F Word like's Kelly Ripa's commercials??
@ceejeemcbeegee: mine, too, except in the bedtime area. When I was six, I was allowed to stay up until 8:30 (I could watch one TV show) and when I was 10, I was watching the 11 o'clock news.
"Mr. Obama is a modern-day dad who leaves the Oval Office for dinner with his girls, rarely misses a parent-teacher conference or piano recital and prides himself on having read all seven books in the Harry Potter series aloud with Malia."
The grey hair articles confuse me. Both my brother and my father were mostly grey by 25. I have several friends who had to start dying their hair in high school because of grey hairs. (The common thread seems to be Irish heritage but it could just be coinsidence).
Wear and tear or thinning make no sense to me. My dad had hair like Ted Kennedy- white as snow but thick enough to knock you over. None of the people I know who have premature greys have thicker looking hair than average.
@clevernamehere: OMG! I have the alleged Irish heritage=prematurely gray hair thing going on, too! I've had gray hairs since middle school. I'm finally starting to embrace them.
Also, according to lore, gray hair on young people means they're geniuses. It hasn't worked out for so far, but I haven't lost hope.
@Eeva: @gangey: @CloudsInMyCoffee: I feel like they were studying normal grey haired people, not the ones who start greying in high school. I saw my first grey (really stark white) hair at 22 and it hasn't spread much. That makes me LUCKY in my family. Grandma rocked white hair at her wedding but no baldies anywhere.
@clevernamehere: That's an interesting coincidence. One of my friends is Irish and has been greyer longer than any of the rest of us.
As for the wear and tear argument, my greys are mostly on my shortest hairs - ie those round my face and my bangs. The long hairs which have seen years of washing aren't grey.
Jamal may have had a happy ending in Slumdog Millionaire, but how many of the other slumdogs in the film did? I won't spoil more of the film, but it's pretty clear in the context of the film that Jamal was the exception.
@Kilotwat: I should point out that even Jamal got brutally tortured by the Indian police, and went through plenty of shit (literal and otherwise) in his life.
@BrutallyHonestZombies: Precisely. Didn't these people have parents who lectured them about finishing what's in front of them? What about the poor children in Africa who don't have any Vicodin?
@MizJenkins: I read it earlier and it's so terrible. What an asshole that guy was. I don't understand how he still had a license if he had already been convicted of vehicular manslaughter years ago and had been ticketed for speeding in the intervening years. It's disgusting.
@SweetSerengeti: I was thinking the same thing until I clicked through the link. Apparently the poop scooping will start when the get the puppy, which hasn't happened yet.
I'm kind of sick of the Slumdog backlash. It is a fairy tale, plain and simple. Ever After doesn't necessarily provide and accurate depiction of feudal fucking farming life either. I mean it's good that people are talking about life in the slums and the problems of poverty because of the film, but there's no point in criticizing it for inaccuracies.
@kelsium: I totally agree. It really bothers me when people sometimes forget the meaning of fiction and fairy tales in entertainment. If you want realism, watch Born into Brothels. The conversation should now be steered toward how to eradicate systemic poverty in India and other countries around the world.
@kelsium: But it was accurate. What happened to Jamal was extraordinary, and that was the point of the film. The other people from the slums, even Jamal's beloved Latika, suffered far crueler fates. The film hardly glosses over any of that. I don't see how anybody can forget that one particularly gruesome scene from the movie...
@kelsium: I'm also irritated because of the Indian popular cinema's attitude towards escapism in general (Um, "pro" - many a protagonist lives in a mansion, there are no servants in sight and they often own helicopters). I watch a lot of Bollywood and I can't think of a single film that even approaches fairy tale levels of realism about the lives of most Indians.
@Kilotwat: That's true, but most of the criticism I've seen is about the story arch itself, which is just ridiculous because of course it is a fairy tale--albeit a very dark one.
@taranwanderer: Exactly! Born into Brothels or Water - both of which are vehemently protested in India for essentially communicating "insider" information.
@Mkp-braaaains-NYC: You know what it is, though? It's that thing where if you are the only woman/minority/film about a foreign country you are expected to be the voice of EVERYONE, and god forbid you are not. It is so absurd.
@kelsium: What's weird too is that most Indian movies are fairy tales. They're just fairy tales about the extremely rich who've always been that way and will always be that way. And therefore represent nobody. Ugh.
@Mkp-braaaains-NYC: ("most" is an exaggeration, but broadly speaking many Bollywood films are fantasy. I mean, they're musicals that feature multiple intracontinental landmarks per musical number)
@kelsium: The rags to riches via Who Wants to be a Millionaire part is unlikely, but not implausible. People do win game shows and lotteries.
A more salient critique would be that winning Millionaire is not a useful solution to most of the slum-dwellers in Mumbai. But even that would miss the mark, as the movie takes quite a bit of pains to show how much luck, effort and endurance went into a victory that was portrayed as unique and extraordinary.
On the other hand, the movie humanizes actual slumdogs. A big moral of the movie is that they shouldn't be underestimated or disrespected (as the Indian Regis did to Jamal). The movie shows the gruesome exploitation and antipathy towards the slums. All of those provide actual solutions.
@Kilotwat: The film also looks at the organizations/NGOs that work with orphans with not-all-that-much oversight. Beggars in India are real, beggar-kings who manipulate, exploit and injure children are real, Slumdog shone a light on those areas even if it couldn't fix them all.
@Kilotwat: Exactly. In the end it was a love story, but there was so much tragedy and death in the whole movie it didn't feel at all like a fairy-tale to me. Watching the older brother grow up from poverty into a life of crime and then meeting that horrible end was heartbreaking.
02/23/09
Like wearing a liver bikini to the dog park.
02/23/09
I think making idols out of people whether it's Duffy, Heath Ledger, etc is a bad idea. We are all human, and when you try to make someone perfect you ruin who they are. I admire Duffy, love her music, and wish I had her talent, but I don't think she's a super woman and neither should anyone else. She's a strong, successful woman but since when did being a strong and successful woman mean you must be a super hero because no mere mortal could produce such a feat?! Perhaps The F Word like's Kelly Ripa's commercials??
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
dying. of. cuteness.
02/23/09
02/23/09
Does.Not.Compute.
02/23/09
I can't believe I've had that wrong all these years.
02/23/09
Wear and tear or thinning make no sense to me. My dad had hair like Ted Kennedy- white as snow but thick enough to knock you over. None of the people I know who have premature greys have thicker looking hair than average.
02/23/09
Also, according to lore, gray hair on young people means they're geniuses. It hasn't worked out for so far, but I haven't lost hope.
02/23/09
Also, mine grow in in huge patches a few months after I'm exceptionally stressed about something. My dissertation was murder on my hair!
02/23/09
And it's got fuck-all to do with hydrogen peroxide in my case; it's genetic.
Now, stop with the bullshit studies and FIND SOME WAY TO REVERSE MY LOSS OF PIGMENTATION, MOTHERFUCKERS.
02/23/09
02/24/09
As for the wear and tear argument, my greys are mostly on my shortest hairs - ie those round my face and my bangs. The long hairs which have seen years of washing aren't grey.
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
I don't understand.
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
A more salient critique would be that winning Millionaire is not a useful solution to most of the slum-dwellers in Mumbai. But even that would miss the mark, as the movie takes quite a bit of pains to show how much luck, effort and endurance went into a victory that was portrayed as unique and extraordinary.
On the other hand, the movie humanizes actual slumdogs. A big moral of the movie is that they shouldn't be underestimated or disrespected (as the Indian Regis did to Jamal). The movie shows the gruesome exploitation and antipathy towards the slums. All of those provide actual solutions.
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
Okaaay, it's been a rough day. Excuse the excessive aggression.
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09
02/23/09