@RitaCamill: What, you don't want to smell like BLAAAAAAKE? Every morning I wake up and rub cigarette butts and cotton balls soaked in whiskey on my pulse points in the hopes of achieving eau de Winehouse.
Girls! Pick a Twilight Team! Would you rather be stalked by a creepy vampire who, with your knowledge or consent, watches you while you sleep, or be kissed by a werewolf after you've already told him no, because no secretly means yes? Both are SO INCREDIBLY ROMANTIC.
@CurtCole: I don't know what your problem is! He wasn't in love with the infant, he was just felt an instant, incredibly strong connection to her and is destined to marry her when he grows up. NOTHING WEIRD ABOUT THAT.
@Annabellie: I don't get the team-picking thing in general. Aren't you supposed to do that with stuff like Jen and Angie, where it could potentially go either way? The books are over (thank god), she picked Edward, and who cares. I'm not about to go placing bets on the 2007 World Series, you know?
Sorry, I subbed in "women" for "people"... I do that sometimes without thinking, similar to how, if i'm going to use a random gender for a hypothetical, I generally say "she". But as to what people are confused about-- People are confused about sex. People are confused about their rights. People are confused about what rape is. People are confused about if, or what, mens rea is required on the part of a man. People are confused about how it is a man can be raped by a woman. People are confused about how women can go back to their rapists and stay with them. People are confused about how survivors react. We need to educate people on all these things. Limiting their porn? Not really the way to do it. Have comprehensive education regarding sex and rights is.
Your attempts to have a reasoned discussion would go better if you stopped to consider all the issues involved. I'm sorry you were raped, and it may be contributing to why you feel so strongly there is a rape culture, but the involvement I have had with women who were raped discussing it has not been to blame the victim. Perhaps the cultural difference varies by region, I don't know. But the culture I see around me? It does not accept rape. The majority of the media I see? It does not accept rape. And I'll admit, I don't watch Fox news, or brainless TV programs, so maybe that's where the acceptance is coming from, but among my peers, rape is simply not accepted.
@5ft of fury: nope, meant to respond to so... grr, internets, moving my posts around.
I am all for changing the ways society and culture view women. I do think that society doesn't treat women with as much respect as it deserves, and in the people I know that does come out in a lot of ways-- but not in an acceptance of rape. I deal more with women who choose to sleep around being judged, and trying to combat that. And, I have mixed feelings of porn of all types, because I find it incredibly boring, and am very torn on the degrading nature of most mainstream porn and disturbed by the unrealistic bodies used-- yet, if i were to watch porn? I would probably want something with some amount of force and degradation to the woman, who I would be identifying with. Power play-- done in a safe manner-- gets me more worked up than sweet equality, for some reason.
I do think there is SO MUCH in society's views towards women that do need to be changed though, so we agree on that point.
@clevernamehere: I'm sorry it sounds condescending to you, that certainly wasn't my intent. I think it would probably sound more coherent if I hadn't accidently posted it in the wrong place, and you could see the discussion that came before this post.
@5ft of fury: I don't think I'm doing that, and I'm not exactly sure what you mean. I do have very mixed feelings on porn-- I don't like that it shows degrading acts-- but I don't feel like the women in porn are being degraded, or that it makes men more likely to degrade them. When I fantasize, I fantasize about degrading or violent things being done to me-- so if I were to watch porn, I would probably want one that matches my fantasies, which would mean I woman I could identify with being degraded. My problem is that, if certain situations in porn were real, I would disapprove of them-- but as long as they stay in fantasy-land, they're fine. My bigger issue with porn is the way women seem to always want sex, to love every position, and be made out of plastic. The appearances and attitudes are degrading. I don't think power play is for everyone, and I wouldn't reccomend anyone try it who isn't comfortable with it, but I don't think porn creates or encourages problems in society. I don't think it normalizes problems. I think its stays in the realm of fantasy. But, the existence of women as only sex objects does bother me. Porn with a plot would be something interesting, though.
We're getting a little off topic. If you want to continue talking beyond this subject, we could take it to PMs?
I guess my big question is why would so many people be turned on by this? Is it really because so much of similiar things are accessible to people now (i.e., porn, video games, horror movies)? I have to wonder because there are A LOT of people with different levels of fascinations with torture, horror, tragedy, whatever. Which came first? The capacity for humans to simply enjoy this? It must... or else these things would not exist.
@ericacartman: I think there are a lot of people who are turned on by rape/domination fantasies without seeing porn-- this porn just exists as an outlet for desires they already have. There may be some people who aren't into until they see it, and for them, it may be the fact that its taboo-- what is taboo is often titillating ,regardless of what that taboo thing is.
Has anybody before you know getting all angry and crap, sat down and saw what the game was about first? Actually sat down and played it through? If people are really offended and angry by stuff like this, how come novels like Lolita and Cry to Heaven aren't banned or thrown in a bonfire. In the end its a lack for a better word an artistic vision, somebody's else perspective. Besides Stolkholm syndrome so interesting.
In response to some of the people who think games/films like this help people get out their kinks in a safe way, I thought the research has shown the opposite. For example, if you punch a pillow to "let off steam" you are actually increasing your anger rather than decreasing it. I would think that the more exposure people have to getting turned onto this, the more they need it to be turned on. While they might not be more likely to kidnap/rape someone in real life, they are certainly not less likely.
Yeah, this is gross, and ethically squishy, and the comments and glee are upsetting. However, I personally cannot get too worked up about this. Rape's not one of my turn ons. Nor has it ever been a turn on for any of my partners. But being turned on by nonconsentual sex and seeking out porn based on that--as long as the porn itself does not depict the sexual assault version of a snuff film, which I have a HUGE problem with--it doesn't make you a rapist. Just a person with different tastes from mine. And I don't have to play along.
@sciencerules: It doesn't make you a rapist, that's true. But it does normalize rape and that is NEVER ok. Honestly, this is one of the few things that makes me judgy. Because yes, sometimes judgement is necessary in order for people to function in society. Part of living in society is agreeing to follow certain rules of behavior and not raping people is one of those rules. If someone's kink is shit like this, I'm just going to say it : I JUDGE YOU. AS A RAPE VICTIM I JUDGE YOU AND WISH TO GOD THAT YOU NEVER HAVE TO FIND OUT WHAT IT REALLY MEANS TO BE RAPED. Agh.
@5ft of fury: I mean, I know where you're coming from--I've been raped too. But I know a lot of women who find the idea of rape--in controlled, fantasy circumstances--very sexy. I can't judge them for that. Reality ruined that one for me, but I can see the appeal.
The male side of it makes me a lot more uncomfortable, like seriously squirmingly uncomfortable, but I have to rationalize that if it's okay for my friend to think about some dude scooping her off the street to have his way with her in a dark alley during her sexy times, then it's okay for a dude to think about that during his sexytimes too. The thing is, rape as a sexual fantasy and ACTUAL rape are so divorced in my head that this goes very firmly in my "not my style, but there's no accounting for taste I suppose" bin.
As for normalizing rape, that's an interesting point. Do you think that the violent video games normalize homicide and make it seem like a more permissible breaking of society's rules? I am thinking here of the seven year old who stole his grandmother's car.
@sciencerules: I think that normalizing behaviors that fall outside of the law isn't good. However, humans have free will and until people have actually committed a crime, they can't be prosecuted and policed. As for women who get off on rape fantasies....I have issue with that. They might not realize this, but it isn't rape that they are getting off on, it is the thought of giving away control to someone. By giving away control, they have made a choice and as I'm sure you know, rape is about a complete lack of choice on the part of the victim. Those women would be suited best for a dominance submission type of sex play, NOT actual rape. I hope that you have impressed to them the difference between the two. As for guys who are drawn to rape fantasies...personally I do judge them and if I found out a guy was attracted to that sort of thing I'd run the other way screaming. Again, it could be a case of the guy mistaking dominance and role play for what it is actually like. Also, the guy who raped me was not suprisingly attracted to dominance and rape play. I don't know how often it happens that someone's kink winds up becoming reality, but it appears that this was the case for him.
@sciencerules: I am turned on by rape fantasy and I still don't think this is ok. There are so many things wrong here...most significantly the first-person perspective and the psychological dimension.
Video games where you kill zombies or "enemies" in combat are one thing, but a DVD that sucks you into the mindset of a serial killer? That gives you the first-hand experience of stalking a victim and pre-meditating how to kill him/her? I think that starts to cross the line from fantasy to facilitation.
@5ft of fury: I'm going to steer this conversation out of the particulars of sexual assault, because that's a very personal and difficult topic for both of us, I would imagine.
No, I definitely understand the difference between lack of control in rape fantasies and the actuality of rape. It's also interesting that many women "choose" their rapist in their fantasies. However, I tend to not be super involved in my friends' sex lives, and I would certainly never feel comfortable suggesting they play around with submission unless they came directly to me with that question.
Plenty of people have sexual bents that make me squeamish. However, part of my recovery process has been thinking through the idea that sex, and what arouses you, and what you seek out to arouse you, is not necessarily a value judgment on the person themselves. People can't control what arouses them. They *can* control what they do. So, the women I know who like the idea of rape, they aren't posting requests for big burly men to come take advantage of them on Craigslist. They just like the idea. Although I am personally uncomfortable with the male equivalent, I have to continue my logic and believe that as long as it isn't translated into action, it's probably not actively harmful.
@MizJenkins: I am going to fully agree with this. There is a genre of rape fantasy porn, which a lot of perfectly normal people watch, but this game falls outside of that genre.
@5ft of fury: Thank you for that reasoned comment about both men and women and so called 'rape fantasies'.
I really really wish women in particular would not use the term 'rape fantasy'. Call it domination, call it overpowering sex...just don't call it 'rape fantasy' as if you can fantasise about all elements of control and choice being removed from you. Surely that implies a consent rape cannot offer?
@MizJenkins: So maybe I'm biased here because of some things I've read. But I've read and really enjoyed Lolita, a first-person account of child kidnapping and rape, and The Collecter, a mostly first-person account of kidnapping and psychological manipulation that features a section from the victim's journal. Granted, both of these main characters are male. But reading and enjoying those books doesn't make me more likely to kidnap anyone, nor does it make me feel like such actions are more acceptable.
Do you think it's because of the medium? Because most people aren't thinking critically about their video games or DVD menus?
@gherkinfiend: The thing that makes it a rape fantasy, and not a domination fantasy is that sure, in your mind you construct what they guy looks like and how he acts, but your fantasy is that you don't have a choice, and that you get off in spite of yourself. In a domination fantasy, you're fantasizing about voluntarily giving up power, and the settings of the fantasies generally differ.
@sciencerules: I think that is a very good point (regarding the medium). Perhaps, because video games are so new (compared to books and film), it seems worse, or more immersive?
I'm sure every Amazon page looks the same way, but I'm slightly creeped out that you can press a button to add this game to either your wedding registry (ah, romance!) or baby registry.
@Asmo: I would like to know why, specifically, you feel that outrage over this is unwarranted. The fact that there may be worse porn does not make this less offensive to me. Why should I support something that equates true love with kidnapping, rape, and brainwashing?
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
Jondalar is a Cro-Magnon.
*takes off glasses*
07/23/09
07/23/09
Team George Hamilton!
07/23/09
@BrutallyHonestBabes (aka Mrs....: Team Willem Dafoe!
07/23/09
@BrutallyHonestBabes (aka Mrs....: Team Gary Oldman! Hey-YO!
07/23/09
@BrutallyHonestBabes (aka Mrs....: Team Gerard Butler!
07/23/09
@CurtCole: I think this is what you mean when you say "Team Gary Oldman."
07/23/09
@BrutallyHonestBabes (aka Mrs....: Team Klaus Kinski!
07/23/09
@BrutallyHonestBabes (aka Mrs....: Klaus Kinski never gets the love.
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
07/23/09
*sigh* Images still not working. (Although I see from the other "team members" that I am the problem.)
07/23/09
@BrutallyHonestBabes (aka Mrs....:
Team David Bowie!
07/23/09
05/29/09
to me
show details 7:34 PM (6 minutes ago)
Reply
Follow up message
Hello,
Thanks for contacting Amazon.com with your concern.
The item you referenced is no longer for sale on our site.
Thank you again for your feedback.
Please let us know if this e-mail resolved your question:
If yes, click here:
[www.amazon.com]
If not, click here:
[www.amazon.com]
Please note: this e-mail was sent from an address that cannot accept incoming e-mail.
To contact us about an unrelated issue, please visit the Help section of our web site.
Best regards,
Vinay G
Amazon.com
We're Building Earth's Most Customer-Centric Company
[www.amazon.com]
FYI. Great job, ladies!
05/29/09
05/30/09
05/29/09
Your attempts to have a reasoned discussion would go better if you stopped to consider all the issues involved. I'm sorry you were raped, and it may be contributing to why you feel so strongly there is a rape culture, but the involvement I have had with women who were raped discussing it has not been to blame the victim. Perhaps the cultural difference varies by region, I don't know. But the culture I see around me? It does not accept rape. The majority of the media I see? It does not accept rape. And I'll admit, I don't watch Fox news, or brainless TV programs, so maybe that's where the acceptance is coming from, but among my peers, rape is simply not accepted.
05/29/09
05/29/09
I am all for changing the ways society and culture view women. I do think that society doesn't treat women with as much respect as it deserves, and in the people I know that does come out in a lot of ways-- but not in an acceptance of rape. I deal more with women who choose to sleep around being judged, and trying to combat that. And, I have mixed feelings of porn of all types, because I find it incredibly boring, and am very torn on the degrading nature of most mainstream porn and disturbed by the unrealistic bodies used-- yet, if i were to watch porn? I would probably want something with some amount of force and degradation to the woman, who I would be identifying with. Power play-- done in a safe manner-- gets me more worked up than sweet equality, for some reason.
I do think there is SO MUCH in society's views towards women that do need to be changed though, so we agree on that point.
05/29/09
05/29/09
@5ft of fury: I don't think I'm doing that, and I'm not exactly sure what you mean. I do have very mixed feelings on porn-- I don't like that it shows degrading acts-- but I don't feel like the women in porn are being degraded, or that it makes men more likely to degrade them. When I fantasize, I fantasize about degrading or violent things being done to me-- so if I were to watch porn, I would probably want one that matches my fantasies, which would mean I woman I could identify with being degraded. My problem is that, if certain situations in porn were real, I would disapprove of them-- but as long as they stay in fantasy-land, they're fine. My bigger issue with porn is the way women seem to always want sex, to love every position, and be made out of plastic. The appearances and attitudes are degrading. I don't think power play is for everyone, and I wouldn't reccomend anyone try it who isn't comfortable with it, but I don't think porn creates or encourages problems in society. I don't think it normalizes problems. I think its stays in the realm of fantasy. But, the existence of women as only sex objects does bother me. Porn with a plot would be something interesting, though.
We're getting a little off topic. If you want to continue talking beyond this subject, we could take it to PMs?
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
The male side of it makes me a lot more uncomfortable, like seriously squirmingly uncomfortable, but I have to rationalize that if it's okay for my friend to think about some dude scooping her off the street to have his way with her in a dark alley during her sexy times, then it's okay for a dude to think about that during his sexytimes too. The thing is, rape as a sexual fantasy and ACTUAL rape are so divorced in my head that this goes very firmly in my "not my style, but there's no accounting for taste I suppose" bin.
As for normalizing rape, that's an interesting point. Do you think that the violent video games normalize homicide and make it seem like a more permissible breaking of society's rules? I am thinking here of the seven year old who stole his grandmother's car.
05/29/09
05/29/09
Video games where you kill zombies or "enemies" in combat are one thing, but a DVD that sucks you into the mindset of a serial killer? That gives you the first-hand experience of stalking a victim and pre-meditating how to kill him/her? I think that starts to cross the line from fantasy to facilitation.
05/29/09
No, I definitely understand the difference between lack of control in rape fantasies and the actuality of rape. It's also interesting that many women "choose" their rapist in their fantasies. However, I tend to not be super involved in my friends' sex lives, and I would certainly never feel comfortable suggesting they play around with submission unless they came directly to me with that question.
Plenty of people have sexual bents that make me squeamish. However, part of my recovery process has been thinking through the idea that sex, and what arouses you, and what you seek out to arouse you, is not necessarily a value judgment on the person themselves. People can't control what arouses them. They *can* control what they do. So, the women I know who like the idea of rape, they aren't posting requests for big burly men to come take advantage of them on Craigslist. They just like the idea. Although I am personally uncomfortable with the male equivalent, I have to continue my logic and believe that as long as it isn't translated into action, it's probably not actively harmful.
05/29/09
05/29/09
I really really wish women in particular would not use the term 'rape fantasy'. Call it domination, call it overpowering sex...just don't call it 'rape fantasy' as if you can fantasise about all elements of control and choice being removed from you. Surely that implies a consent rape cannot offer?
05/29/09
Do you think it's because of the medium? Because most people aren't thinking critically about their video games or DVD menus?
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
The Great American Snuff Film
Gutterballs (Ws Unct)
Silip: Daughters of Eve
Etc.
Disgusting.
05/29/09
05/29/09
Don't mind me though, I'm just some guy who's been playing video games since I was 5. Please, carry on with the unwarranted outrage.
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09
05/29/09