Well, I'm not going to lie to you, today's comments had their minds in the gutter — everywhere I looked it was "suck this" and "blowjob that". In keeping with the spirit (you chose this path, not me!), COTD goes to StannisBaratheon for opening up the can of worms about penis length and fuck lists:
Do women keep lists of the biggest dongs they ever had? Cause I'm not gonna be on anyone's list.
And then all those responses! This is a passionate topic for passionate people.
Submit nominations to the Comment of the Day tag page. Click on the comment's time stamp, and post the comment's URL to the forum. (Replying to a comment with "#cotd" does not work; you need to go to the forum.) For meetups, use the meetup forum!