It turns out Willow, the cat who turned up in New York five years after she ran away from her home in Colorado, didn't make it across the country on her own. Many theorized that Willow was adopted by a new owner, as she was very healthy when she was found (and lacks the opposable thumbs necessary for hitchhiking). A reader sent this tip to Gothamist:
Kinja is in read-only mode. We are working to restore service.