Why Did Crystal Harris Call Off Her Wedding To Hugh Hefner?

Crystal Harris's very first wedding — and Hugh Hefner's third — had been scheduled for Saturday, but now it may never happen. According to reports, the Playboy Playmate of the Month (December 2009) got into a fight with Hef over the phone. After she hung up, she promptly packed and moved out.

What would make a happy go-lucky 25-year-old gal break up with her rich, famous, 85-year-old boyfriend? Hugh claims Crystal had a "change of heart." But we're skeptical. Something big must have gone down.

Some guesses:

  • Hugh cheated.
  • Crystal realized not having a prenup was a huge mistake.
  • Crystal realized that Hef is not actually avuncular TV character Thurston Howell III.
  • Crystal realized she was marrying a man who was rather selfish in bed, or, at least, really into taking Viagra, covering himself in baby oil and having a blonde suck his nipple while he watches porn.
  • They're not actually broken up: It's a publicity stunt to get better ratings for the wedding special, which is supposed to air on Lifetime July 13.
  • Crystal is pregnant and Hugh wants her to get an abortion (This would be the answer if their life were a plotline from The Young And The Restless).
  • Crystal had a literal "change" of "heart" when a wise old shaman of an obscure Aztec cult kidnapped her and performed a weird mystical spell splash surgery, giving her the heart of an ancient diety. Crystal — now known as Ayauhteotl, goddess of fog and fame — has renounced her worldly possessions and false lashes and is currently in Mexico teaching children to crochet bikinis.

One more possibility: Crystal has a man on the side.

Back in March, Life & Style claimed that Crystal Harris was secretly dating Dr. Phil's son, Jordan McGraw. As we wrote in Midweek Madness:

They were spotted cozying up to each other at Chateau Marmont on March 14. Jordan was seen kissing her shoulder and trying to hold her hand - the one with the six carat engagement ring on it! A source says they've been sneaking around because Crystal is supposed to be happily engaged to Hef. Now what?

Today, Life & Style insists that Crystal and Jordan had been dating. Crystal's rep says that the decision to call of the wedding was "mutual," even though Hef's Tweet certainly made it seem like it was Crystal's idea. In any case, Crystal's rep leaves us with the most oft-repeated lie in the biz: "The split was amicable and I'm happy to say that Crystal and Hef will remain close friends."

Hugh Hefner's Fiancée Calls Off Wedding-Just Five Days Out! [E!]
Life & Style Exclusive: Crystal's Other Man [Life & Style]

Earlier: But Hef, What About Holly Madison?