New York Times Bets Against Anna Wintour, American VogueTatianaTheAnonymousModel1/02/09 11:00amFiled to: Critical DistancemaghagAnna WintourConde NastCathy HorynNew York TimesFashionAnna Wintour DeathwatchGawkerTop1152EditPromoteShare to KinjaToggle Conversation toolsGo to permalinkTimes fashion critic Cathy Horyn is famous for her willingness to dose the industry with healthy perspective. So how delicious is Horyn's savaging of Vogue as "stale and predictable"? And that's just a warm up!Horyn's critical voice is so fresh that she is regularly uninvited from even the most high-profile shows — her ban list, of which she seems perversely proud, has included Dolce & Gabbana, Giorgio Armani, Carolina Herrera, Helmut Lang, and Nicole Miller. It's no surprise that the flagship newspaper critics, particularly Horyn, Suzy Menkes at the International Herald Tribune and the incomparable Robin Givhan at the Washington Post are often some of the sanest voices in fashion, and, like the scrappier bloggers, the most willing to lay hands upon the industry's sacred cows: fashion magazines, as we all pretty much know, are too deeply compromised by their advertising to attempt any independent analysis of designers' wares. (Trust me, you don't want to know how many times a fashion editor has thrust a not-quite-matching item on me at a shoot with a remark about how the magazine needs the editorial credit line because the label is an advertiser.)ShareTweet Kinja is in read-only mode. We are working to restore service.