20 Minutes with an American Girl Author at a '50s Diner in Times Square

“I love writing for this age level,” said Valerie Tripp, talking about her American Girl books. She’s written for Molly, Felicity, and Josefina. “Sometimes it’s the first independent chapter book that a girl has read and—it’s like it belongs to her.”

We were sitting in a determinedly retro booth in Times Square’s kitschy Stardust Diner, practically yelling at each other over waitstaff singing show tunes. Tripp, across from me, smiled in a cheerful bright-teal jacket. “We call Valerie American Girl royalty,” a company rep had informed me. Tripp was explaining the fierce connection between girls and her characters, which she didn’t really need to explain to me, because—like so many women in my demo—an American Girl book was probably my first independent chapter book, too.

“She’s the one who is Molly’s friend,” she explained. “She’s making it happen. She’s flexing that imagination muscle.”

“It’s sort of universal and intimate at the same time,” Tripp added.

The Pleasant Company had invited me to the launch of Maryellen Larkin, their latest addition to their historical line—now called “BeForever.” Like Tripp herself (who wrote the new books), she’s a child of the 1950s. The company had scattered Maryellen’s various “sets” around the mezzanine and invited several parent-child pairs to come see. A reporter from PIX11 periodically hoisted a Maryellen doll into the air for a live shot, while families ate complimentary pancake breakfasts. Each table had been equipped with purpose-built American Girl doll seats.

Tripp has been with the company since the beginning. She was friends with Pleasant Rowland, the eponymous founder, who called her one day. “She said, ‘Okay, I’ve got this idea. We’re gonna write books about girls who live in different periods of history,’” Tripp recalled. “And I was like, ‘Pleasant, That’s great.’ And then she said, ‘And—there’ll be dolls based on the characters and clothes and furniture and everything.’ And I said, ‘Pleasant, that’s just ridiculous.’ But she had the whole vision from the very, very beginning.”

Apologies, however, if you think that your personality can be wholly defined by your allegiance to a particular American Girl historical character. “We are none of us one thing all the time. Sometimes you want to be the impulsive Felicity. And then sometimes—Maryellen is just sort of goodnatured and exuberant and ebullient. And then other times you’re Samantha, very thoughtful. But none of us can be thoughtful all the time!” said Tripp.

“I think it’s great that the reader can choose who she’s in the mood for, as well,” she added, straining to be heard over a waiter singing a medley from Grease. “We’re all more varied and fluid than we’re given credit for being.”

Tripp also writes a series of books for boys, set at a summer camp, which she said were fun to write because “those are adventures,” she said. But she refuses to keep her American Girls cordoned off from that sort of plot. “For example in the Maryellen book, I wanted her to have a physically dangerous adventure. Girls aren’t hothouse violets. They get muddy. Her sister falls down a bank towards a river. I wanted to show girls like adventures too.”

“I try to have the girls make as many mistakes, and I try to have the boys be as nurturing and thoughtful,” she added. “I just don’t believe that traits are necessarily related to a gender.”

“Girly” accessories, however, are undeniably a crucial element of the American Girl appeal. This fall, for instance, the company is teaming up with William Sonoma to sell branded bakeware (in child and adult sizes, of course). I watched girl after girl pause before Maryellen’s vignettes—for instance, a diner in bright colors and a midcentury foldout couch/TV combo, all so period-perfect they must’ve been designed with nostalgic, wallet-wielding mothers and grandmothers in mind—stopping to stare, then run her little hands over doll hair and doll dresses and doll accessories.

But, it’s probably a willingness to walk the line between girly-ness and a dedication to recognizing girls as independent actors who aren’t defined by their girly-ness that’s traditionally made the company truly beloved. Think of Molly’s summertime adventure, which culminates in the character using what she knows about D-Day for her camp’s cutthroat game of capture the flag. Think of The Care and Keeping of You, the company’s frank guide to puberty. Compare an American Girl store at its most terrifying to Disney’s princesses, who—until Frozen, anyway—have always come equipped with a prince.

Of course, the company looks very different these days. Spokesperson Julie Parks pointed to the recent revamp, which retooled the packaging and presentation for today’s customer, and insisted that, “We consider BeForever and the historical line core to everything we do. It is incredibly important to us.” But if you haven’t paged through a catalog since your tween years, it might be a little jarring. Molly and Felicity are gone, for instance, as of 2014 and 2011 respectively, and your average kid is more likely to plead for a lookalike “TrulyMe” doll or a Girl of the Year.

Tripp doesn’t worry, though. “When you write, you’re not going broad—you’re going deep,” she explained. “I’m hopeful that I’ll always have my readers who love historical fiction and are curious about American history and love the books as deeply as girls did when they first came out.”

“The company had to grow and change,” she added. “The world is different. Though I’m not really sure girls are all that different.”